Kelleys Island

Situated in Lake Erie and part of Erie County, this small island community recorded a population of 198 residents and a notably high owner-occupied rate of 93.5 percent, reflecting the tight-knit, seasonal nature of the local housing market. With just 7 active listings currently available, inventory remains limited, and the median home price sits at $599,900. Buyers can expect to pay approximately $321 per square foot, with average home sizes around 1,714 square feet. The median household income stands at $91,875, suggesting a relatively affluent permanent resident base despite the modest population count. The Kelleys Island Local School District serves the area. The combination of scarce inventory, waterfront access, and low population density tends to support price stability, making this an illiquid but sought-after market for buyers pursuing island property in northern Ohio. Those considering a purchase should be prepared for limited turnover and competitive conditions when desirable homes do become available.

Market description generated from current MLS and U.S. Census data.