New Middletown

Tucked into Mahoning County, this small unincorporated community of roughly 1,600 residents carries a notably high owner-occupancy rate of 74.5%, signaling stable, long-term household investment in the area. The current market is tight, with only 8 active listings available, which can limit options for buyers but tends to support consistent pricing. The median home price sits at $264,750, with sellers averaging $226 per square foot across homes that typically run around 1,832 square feet. That size-to-price ratio positions New Middletown competitively within the broader Mahoning County market for buyers seeking modest square footage without the density of larger nearby cities. The median household income of $50,833 reflects a working-class base, and homes here fall within the Springfield Local School District. Buyers drawn to low-traffic residential streets and a close-knit community footprint will find the inventory scarce but the ownership landscape well-established.

Market description generated from current MLS and U.S. Census data.